arc	title	authors	discussion	topic	status	created
1	ARC Proposal Guidelines	The Aleo Team <hello@aleo.org>		Meta	Living	2020-02-07

Abstract

Aleo Request for Comments (ARCs) are protocol-level, network-level, and application-level standards for the Aleo ecosystem.

Specification

ARC standards proposals should be labeled with one of the following categories:

• Protocol: all core features, system parameters, consensus upgrades, and cryptographic protocols
• Network: all communication protocols, message formats, and RPC standards
• Application: all application-level standards and conventions
• Meta: all informational and general-purpose notices

Process

graph LR
    subgraph authors
        draft([Draft]) --> active([Active])
    end

    draft([Draft]) -.-> withdrawn([Withdrawn])
    active([Active]) -.-> withdrawn([Withdrawn])
    
    subgraph standards
        active([Active]) --> decision{Decision}
        decision{Decision} --> accepted([Accepted])
    end
    
    decision{Decision} -.-> rejected([Rejected])

    subgraph standards
        accepted([Accepted]) --> final([Final])
        accepted([Accepted]) --> living([Living])
        final([Final]) -.-> deprecated([Deprecated])
    end

Loading

Draft refers to a proposal that is currently undergoing development and is not ready for review.

Active refers to a proposal with a reference implementation that is ready for review.

Withdrawn refers to a proposal that was previously marked as Idea, Draft, or Active.

Accepted refers to a proposal that was Active with a reference implementation, and has been approved by reviewer(s).

Rejected refers to a proposal that was Active with a reference implementation, and has been denied by reviewer(s).

Final refers to a proposal that was Accepted, and the reference implementation has been incorporated into Aleo.

Deprecated refers to a proposal that has been superseded or replaced by a new proposal that is now marked as Final.

Living refers to a proposal that was Accepted and intended to remain as a living document.